Thursday, May 5th, 2011

Court rules in favor of St. Marys in police harassment case

By Amy Kronenberger
ST. MARYS - Mercer County Common Pleas Court ruled in favor of the St. Marys Police Department after the city pursued a lawsuit for frivolous litigation.
The court ruled that Charles Black of Rockford must pay all attorney fees incurred by the city totaling $36,502 for needlessly suing the department on 16 different charges.
"Based upon the evidence presented at the hearing ... it appears that none of Black's claims are warranted under existing law nor can they be supported by any good faith argument, though none was made, for the establishment of new law," the court ruling said.
In April 2010, Mercer County Common Pleas Judge Jeffrey Ingraham dismissed the case Black filed against the St. Marys Police Department and officer Tom Kennedy. Black then appealed the case, and The Third District Court of Appeals in October agreed with Ingraham. The city then pursued the frivolous litigation lawsuit.
The original suit filed by Black and his daughter Stephanie in June 2009 alleged Kennedy trespassed on their Lombard Road property to serve Stephanie Black with a citation of operating a vehicle while under the influence.
Charles Black had told The Daily Standard he asked Kennedy to leave his property six times, but the officer refused and threatened to arrest him for disrupting official business.
According to the police report, Black threatened to physically remove Kennedy. "Black then drove a 10-ton backhoe towards Kennedy's police cruiser with the intent of removing Kennedy from his property," the report says.
Kennedy called for assistance from the Mercer County Sheriff's Department. Upon arrival of sheriff's deputy Dan Adams, Black acquiesced and allowed Kennedy to deliver the citation.
After the incident, the Blacks sued the St. Marys Police Department and Kennedy for the following offenses: trespassing, negligence, harassment, slander, conspiracy, disorderly conduct, breach of confidence, breach of closeness with a deadly weapon, breach of duty, coercion, assault, malice, inciting violence, malfeasance, malicious abuse of legal process and invasion of property.
Additional online stories on this date
St. Marys man recovering from injuries in Afghanistan
ST. MARYS - Relearning to write, tie his shoes and button his shirt is the new normal for a local soldier injured fighting terrorism in Afghanistan. [More]
GRAND LAKE - Two pairs of eagles on Grand Lake have hatched young.
The eaglets hatched a few days apart about April 9 or 10, said Jill Bowers, a volunteer eagle watcher for the Ohio Division of Wildlife. [More]
Last Curtain Call
As the gate in the Trautman Field outfield fence swung open and Mike Schumm marched his Parkway baseball team through the grass toward an overwhelming sea of fans in the bleachers, his nerves were working in overdrive. [More]
Subscriber and paid stories on this date
CELINA - More than 80 area students must get another shot in the arm because the vaccine they received may be ineffective.
Local health officials d
COLDWATER - A summer job more than 60 years ago cast Doris Durnell-Desch into a slice of American history.
She and her sister, JoAnn, were in thei
CELINA - The health department has hired a new fiscal management director to handle budget and other financial issues.
Aaron Mayes, who operates A&
CELINA - Two downtown businessmen want the city to limit parking time in front of their stores to free up space for customers.
Bob Heitkamp, owner
CELINA - Time is running out for the city to use a $10,000 grant to build a skatepark since there is no location selected or plan in place.
The cit
ST. MARYS - Patrick McGowan edged ahead of Chris Botkin in the Republican mayoral primary Tuesday, winning by only 36 votes.
McGowan received 416 votes while Botkin received 380. Third candidate Dennis Dedrick received 190 votes.
St. Marys facility's ER rated among the top five percent in the country
ST. MARYS - Joint Township District Memorial Hospital last year received quality awards from state and national organizations.
Hospital CEO Kevin H
Minster
MINSTER - The celebration started Wednesday afternoon when officials at Minster Local Schools learned just four ballots remain to be counted - not 80 as they had been told - for the district's 1 percent income tax levy that was narrowly approved by voters.
Rockford
ROCKFORD - Pet owners soon will have to clean up after their pets or face penalties.
Village council gave first reading to an ordinance Tuesday tha
A music maker and a teller of stories, Turkish drummer Hakan Kaya will be a highlight of free children's activities at Wright State University-Lake Campus next week.
COLDWATER - After New Knoxville tied the game at 2-all in the top of the seventh inning on a wild pitch, Coldwater came back with Alex Stammen scorin
FORT RECOVERY - Plenty of in-game promotions helped bring Fort Recovery fans to the baseball diamond, but the action on the field only pleased St. Henry's supporters.
Local Roundup
Compiled by Ryan Hines and Gary R. Rasberry
St. John's pushed a run across the plate in the top of the fifth and edged New Bremen 3-2 in a rescheduled Midwest Athletic Conference contest in New Bremen on Wednesday.