Today
79°
Mostly Sunny
Tonight
59°
Mostly Clear
Tomorrow
84°
Mostly Sunny
5%
Tomorrow Night
68°
Slight Chance Thunderstorms
26%
Thursday
78°
Rain Showers
88%
Thursday Night
64°
Chance Thunderstorms
38%
Friday
78°
Slight Chance Thunderstorms
18%
Friday Night
57°
Mostly Clear
5%
Saturday
78°
Partly Sunny
Saturday Night
58°
Mostly Clear
6%
Sunday
80°
Partly Sunny
7%
Sunday Night
61°
Mostly Clear
11%
3 Day
Extended
Thursday, December 6th, 2012

State must pay more quickly

Court finds ODNR in contempt for slow action in spillway suit

By Nancy Allen
GRAND LAKE - The Ohio Supreme Court on Wednesday found the state in contempt for moving too slowly to compensate 87 landowners for increased flooding on their land caused by Grand Lake's West Bank spillway.
The justices, just one day after the hearing, ruled the state must complete land appraisals within 90 days and file motions for compensation within four months in Mercer County Common Pleas Court for the majority of the cases.
The landowners own 91 parcels, mostly farmland, totaling about 2,400 acres downstream from the state-owned and operated spillway.
For 20 parcels - which involve flooding above the 2003 level upon which the case is based - the state is ordered to institute declaratory judgement actions in the local court within 30 days to determine the landowners' rights. The court denied a request by landowners to pay attorney fees and a fine associated with the hearing.
The justices, in a 5-2 vote, said the landowners had shown "clear and convincing evidence" the state was in contempt of the court's Dec. 1, 2011, decision ordering compensation.
The state has only filed motions for compensation hearings for eight of the 53 cases. Six were filed within the last week and the other two were in August.
Bruce Ingram, the attorney for the landowners, on Wednesday said his clients have been vindicated.
"By ordering the compensation cases to commence in 120 days, the deliberate foot dragging and delay by ODNR ends today," he said. "The landowners look forward to their day in court where compensation will finally be awarded for the state's illegal seizure of their land."
In a written statement, the state promised to use all resources available to speed up the process.
"We will take all the necessary steps to accelerate the pace at which we are doing exactly what the Ohio Supreme Court asked us to do originally," ODNR spokeswoman Bethany McCorkle said.
Justices Judith Lanzinger and Evelyn Lundberg Stratton dissented, saying the state has been moving forward and that a settlement offer last year showed the state was making an effort.
The state withdrew a settlement offer of $24 million, about $5,000 per acre, when presented with a counteroffer of about $27 million, which included an additional $3 million for business owners and homeowners without farms.
The cost of the settlement will go up the longer appraisals take because land values in the area are rising, justices noted during Tuesday's hearing. Ingram on Wednesday said the final settlements could be closer to $50 million.
The state's attorney, Michael Stokes, has said it was extraordinarily difficult to find appraisers who were qualified and willing to do the work and that the state expected to have all cases filed in the local court by the end of 2013.
Additional online story on this date
Especially around this area, there has always been a good family tradition when it comes to athletics.
As the final seconds ticked away in Saturday's Division V state championship football game, the Tom Klosterman family of Coldwater experienced an unique continuation of tradition. [More]
Subscriber only stories on this date
Coldwater schools facing suit
Burned lake condos making comeback
Educators want to alter tests leading to retentions
Failing septic systems also lake problem
Retired educators throw their efforts behind pottery business
Smashing Pumpkins perform a mix of new and familiar tunes
Gelhaus heading to Saginaw Valley State for basketball
Running with weights helped Nedderman
Waves pick up several wins at Lebanon